Quality Groundwork

All guides

HARA and FMEA: what each one is for

Customers ask suppliers for a HARA, an FMEA, or both. They are both ways of thinking about risk before something goes wrong, and they answer different questions.

HARA: could the product harm someone?

A hazard analysis and risk assessment looks at each step of your process and asks what could get into or onto the product that would harm the person using it or spoil your customer's product. Hazards fall into three families: physical, chemical and microbiological. Each hazard is rated for how likely it is and how severe it would be, and the high ones get a specific control.

FMEA: could the process fail to do its job?

A failure mode and effects analysis looks at each step and asks how it could fail, what the effect would be, and what would cause it. Each cause is scored for severity, occurrence and detection, and the three scores are multiplied into a risk priority number that helps rank what to fix first.

The difference in one line

A HARA is about product safety. An FMEA is about the process meeting its requirements, which includes safety and also fit, function, count and labeling.

Which one is being asked for?

  • Suppliers of packaging and materials for food, hygiene and personal care products are most often asked for a HARA.
  • Suppliers approving a new item or process, especially to engineered or measured requirements, are most often asked for a process FMEA.
  • If the request is unclear, ask the customer for the form or the standard they are working to.

What they share

Both are done by a small team that knows the process, both are written in a table with one row per risk, and both go out of date. Review them when a material, machine, supplier or product changes, after a complaint, and at least once a year.

Courses on this topic

Start with the free course. Introduction to Plant Quality takes about 40 minutes and ends with a dated certificate of training.

Start the free course